Slop and the Jevons paradox
Draft, still being revised
On my old homepage in 2002 I wrote about electronic music: because home computers are cheap and easy to use, anyone can make this kind of music. In brackets after that came a remark about quality and quantity. In the same paragraph I recommended Aphex Twin.
Today the same is happening with AI, only not to one genre of music but to everything: texts, images, videos, music and also software. What comes out of it in bulk is called “slop” online. Slopfest takes up the term. My entry there was made entirely from code written by an AI, in Strudel.
Behind this is the Jevons paradox. In 1865 William Stanley Jevons noticed that better steam engines did not reduce the consumption of coal but increased it: what gets cheaper gets used more. When music, text or software become cheaper to make, we do not get less of them but far more.
Quantity was not the problem then and it is not the problem now. The good pieces came out of the same cheap technology back then. When making something costs almost nothing, the idea and the selection are what count.