Harald Schilly

← Thoughts

Open formats matter more than open software

Draft, still being revised

On my old homepage in 2002 I defended free software: open code is more secure because many eyes check it, just like encryption algorithms, which are deliberately made public today. As a general rule that is wrong. Free code is only really checked when it is actually in use, and often it is commercial companies that do the checking. The Heartbleed bug sat unnoticed in OpenSSL for over two years, although almost the whole web relied on it, until it was found in 2014. The backdoor in xz was noticed in 2024 by a developer at Microsoft, more or less by chance, because a login took half a second too long.

The same page said that OpenOffice stores its documents as “a bunch of XML files in a ZIP”. Today I think that is the more important point. Open formats matter more than open software. Software is becoming more plentiful, cheaper and more tailored. An example from this autumn: the company ArtCraft rebuilt Word, Excel and PowerPoint in Rust, with much of the code written by an AI. Programs like these now appear quickly and disappear again.

What lasts is how machines talk to each other: protocols like HTTP, the serialisation of data into file formats, and in each case the meaning behind them. That is a thousand times more important than any single program. As long as a format is open and well described, anyone can write a new program for it, or have one written.